daVinci system not all it’s cracked up to be


In regards to the “news release” in your paper recently publishes about the daVinci assisted robotic surgery system, there are some disadvantages the readers should know about and are not mentioned in the story. Maybe someone from your staff forgot to vet the article, and the following information is taken from Wikipedia. So there is no bias regarding the information found on Wikipedia, anyone can look at it.

Here are a few of the issues not mentioned in the news release that should have been included for the welfare of those considering this type of surgery.

1.) The practitioners must have a long learning curve and additional training in this new modality is essential. Guidelines are still being established for what establishes “sufficient training” but it’s generally thought that 12 to 18 cases of robotic surgery must be done for the surgeon to “adapt.”

2.) Since it’s a new surgical system, the operations can sometimes take twice as long and this can result in prolonged periods under anesthesia, which can cause problems.

3.) The cost of the daVinci robotic system is usually near $2 million, so there will be a greater incentive for the surgeons to use it. The insurance companies do not pay for additional reimbursement for this robotic system, since the outcome is generally the same as traditional surgery.

There are benefits, no doubt, but do these other factors give the patient a truly better outcome? I suppose time and the experience of the surgeons will tell. It is important for the public to know that there are alternative problems that can happen with even the newest and most “state-of-the-art” medical technology.

El Dorado Hills

Short URL: http://www.villagelife.com/?p=33323

This story falls on page "5"
Posted by on Jul 21 2013.
Last Login:
Filed under Letters to the Editor. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

Comments are closed

Recently Commented

  • Paul Reinke: Looks like it’s going to be a very colourful and interesting programme especially with the dance...
  • Jim Vindler: Nice story- very sad- how old was she?
  • Merrilee Posner: Bravo Mr. Divine, thank you for capturing a very influential fact. It reveals as much about Beth...
  • Eric Divine: After reading this article I thought how amazing that this candidate would give up her prestigious state...
  • Ellen Van Dyke: After trying in vain to reach Beth for weeks, and having listened to both candidates at the LWV...