Publisher’s ink: ‘Paper or plastic’ might be dumped

By From page A5 | March 06, 2013

“Will that be paper or plastic?” the grocery store clerk asked.

Years ago brown paper bags (or sacks as some folks refer to them) were the only game in town. Growing up in our household, we saved our paper grocery bags. We re-used them to line the kitchen trash container. And at the beginning of the every new school year, we covered our textbooks with the stiff brown paper.

You could say they were a multi-use product. Like newspapers, paper grocery bags are biodegradable, so one needn’t feel guilty about disposing them outright.

Today, grocery stores provide customers a choice in bags — paper or plastic. Plastic bags are less expensive than paper, take up very little shelf space at the end of the checkout line, and are more durable.

According to an article appearing in a regional newspaper last week, Sacramento City Council members are entertaining a new city ordinance that would ban all plastic bag use by grocery, discount and drug stores.

Advocates for the ban claim they’re causing pollution and wreaking havoc on fish. Too many of the bags are finding their way into waterways including the Pacific Ocean.

Those voicing angst at plastic bags are referring to them as “single-use” shopping bags. “Single-use” is apparently the new buzz phrase environmentalists are throwing around to justify their objective of banning any product they deem harmful to the environs.

Ask any responsible dog owner and they will attest to the invaluable “multi-use” of plastic grocery bags. We currently have three dogs living under our roof. Our oldest daughter and her dog are temporarily staying with us. This has put a serious dent in my plastic bag inventory. Walking three dogs at the same time is challenging enough. Try picking up what they leave behind without a plastic grocery bag and … I think you get the picture.

Multiply three dogs by seven days a week and one can easily see how imperative plastic bags are in our family. The extra mouth to feed (my daughter’s and not necessarily her dog) does require the purchase of additional food. This helps increase our bag count.

A savvy bagging strategy is also helpful.

“Why are you placing the cream cheese in a bag by itself?” my wife asked during a recent shopping foray.

“Don’t want to damage it,” I replied.

She quickly caught on to my scheme when she noticed I was double-bagging the plastic ketchup bottle.

These so called “single-use” bags are used for more than just toting my bread, chips and hotdogs home from the store. Last month for example, after cleaning our outside grill, I used several of them to dispose of the grease.

If opponents of plastic grocery bags are so bent on eliminating this product on the grounds it causes pollution, then why stop there? What about doing away with plastic straws and drink lids provided by fast food restaurants? And why hasn’t anyone proposed legislation outlawing plastic water bottles? Aren’t these single-use products? And just how are plastic grocery bags originating in Sacramento getting into the Pacific Ocean via the landfill?

At last count more than 50 California localities have passed legislation banning plastic bags. In Sacramento’s case, not only would they ban plastic bags but also force stores to ding customers with an additional charge for their paper bags. Yes you read that correctly — a paper bag fee.

Oh now I get it. Restrict the use of plastic bags, force a charge on paper bags and then return the tax back to the stores. This in the minds of the legislators provides cover for the stores when angry customers accuse them of charging for bags the store should be providing for free in the first place.

Perhaps if Sacramento legislators picked up more dog poop instead of dumping more of their crap on consumers and businesses they’d learn the difference between single-use, multi-use and the value of plastic over paper.

Richard Esposito is publisher of the Mountain Democrat. His column appears each Wednesday.

Richard Esposito

Discussion | 1 comment

  • Susan JohnsonMarch 03, 2013 - 2:14 pm

    I remember when sorting our trash first came to my home; recycling was a pain and we couldn't imagine they day that it would just be second nature. But here it is RECYCLE is now the rage. So we are now moving on and taking on one more change that is going to require some getting use to. My daughter lives in San Jose and this law has been in effect there quite sometime. I always carry reusable cloth bags in my car for groceries, etc. in an attempt to be a conscientious shopper but I always end up at check-out and have left them in the car. I just smile and think next time I'll remember but I never do. So the habit hasn't come to be even though the thought is there. So guess what happens when I visit my daughter and go to the store, be it grocery or target or Macy's; absolutely, there I am at check-out with two hands and no bags to hold my purchases. I am left with the choice of carrying loose items to the car like at Costco or purchasing a bag. Now, the people that live in San Jose have developed the habit and don't have this problem any longer. I am just saying change is hard to get use to but sometimes a little step toward good can make a big difference down the green road and last time I looked I was still able to purchase doggie poop bags on-line and at the pet store. Just remember not all people are as responsible with those plastic bags as you are or I wouldn't see them stuck in all the bushes along the roads.



  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • Follow Us On Facebook

  • Special Publications »

    Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service (updated 4/30/2015) and Privacy Policy (updated 4/7/2015).
    Copyright (c) 2017 McNaughton Newspapers, Inc., a family-owned local media company that proudly publishes the Daily Republic, Mountain Democrat, Davis Enterprise, Village Life, Winters Express, Georgetown Gazette, EDC Adventures, and other community-driven publications.