Featured Stories

Skeel files claim against CSD

By From page A1 | March 07, 2012

John Skeel has begun the process of suing his former employer, the El Dorado Hills Community Services District. On Feb. 26 he filed a tort claim against the district, outlining his claims against several named parties in broad strokes, a procedural prerequisite to a lawsuit that seeks as yet unspecified damages.

The claim alleges the district violated the former GM’s three-year employment contract by failing to establish “good cause” to support his termination.

It states that Skeel was convinced to leave a “very good position” as executive director of the Park and Recreation District in Evergreen, Colo., and move his wife and three children to California.

The tort outlines Skeel’s brief tenure as GM, which effectively ended in June 2011 when he was placed on administrative leave — the affair lingering through December when he was terminated.

Under California law the district has 45 days to accept the claim and settle with Skeel or reject it, after which Skeel has six months to file a lawsuit.

SDRMA to the rescue
The Special District Risk Management Association, a public agency that pools risk for its 460 members and provides defense counsel in employment practice lawsuits, is representing the CSD in the Skeel case.

SDRMA Risk Officer Dennis Timoney explained that the agency collects fees, assesses risk and covers settlements for its members, but is a Joint Powers Authority, not an insurance company.

“We don’t’ knee jerk react the way a commercial carrier would,” said Timoney. “We don’t drop clients just because there has been an adverse action.”

He confirmed that the agency is currently defending the district in the Debbie Kiley lawsuit as well, but that neither case would approach the district’s coverage limits or result in major fee increases.

“The El Dorado Hills CSD has been a respected member of SDRMA for years,” he said. “We’re not going to run away in their time of need. Stuff happens and now we need to work through it for the benefit of all parties involved, including John Skeel.”

Any Skeel lawsuit would end up in the superior court system, he added.

The SDRMA has hired Sacramento attorney James Ward of Evans, Wieckowski & Ward, LLP to represent the CSD in the Skeel case.

Skeel is represented by Roseville attorneys Ellen Arabian-Lee and David Daniels of Gurnee & Daniels, LLP, who made their public El Dorado Hills debut in dramatic fashion during the loud public airing of charges against Skeel on Aug. 23, 2011.

All parties are scheduled to meet in private on March 29 for a mediation, according to Arabian-Lee. Retired Yuba County Superior Court Judge Thomas Hill will be overseeing the negotiation, which could result in a settlement agreement.

Billy gets a pass
The claim names four of the five sitting CSD directors — Guy Gertsch, Noelle Mattock, Wayne Lowery and Tony Rogozinski. Director Bill Vandegrift, who voted for Skeel’s suspension but against his termination, gets a pass.

Also named are Human Resources Manager Tracey Lynn Lowry, Assistant GM Sandi Kukkola and district legal counsel Bob Thurbon and Lindsay Moore.

Witnesses that might substantiate the claim were identified as anyone working for the CSD between January and June 2011, former employees Deborah Kiley (who’s also suing the district), Janice McGrath, Kim Grinnell and Renee Scherr, plus anyone present at the Aug. 23 hearing.

Claim details

The claim traces the origins of Skeel’s fall from grace to complaints about his health insurance, after which the named parties allegedly fabricated charges in an attempt to find cause to terminate him.

The results constitute “breach of contract, intentional and negligent misrepresentation, negligence, wrongful termination in violation of public policy, including whistleblower claims, retaliation, and statutory violations, including the Brown Act,” according to the claim

The claim also alleges that the claimants violated Skeel’s due process rights, failing to allow him to question key witnesses and stating publicly that they were working with him to get him back to work while actively talking to potential replacements.

Skeel is struggling to find another position because his “previously exemplary employment record has been permanently tarnished,” by “false statements about his job performance which constitute defamation of his character,” according to the claim.

Skeel also contends that as general manager, attorneys Thurbon and Moore owed him an attorney-client relationship, and that when he sought their legal advice, they divulged a proposed confidential reorganization plan to the board which contributed to his ultimate dismissal.

Mike Roberts

Discussion | 2 comments

  • DisgustedMarch 05, 2012 - 11:52 am

    The clowns on this Board need to go back to the circus they came from. The residents of our community deserve far better representation than what we have had to put up with for the last 3 years. Not only has this Board wasted our tax dollars, they have apparently manipulated and lied to us to serve their own personal egos and agendas. I am disgusted by this Board, and can only hope that this mess gets settled without any more of their incompitent actions. I call on all residents to demand that this Board step aside immediatley and make room for a Board who cares about this community.

  • Very Concerned ResidentMarch 07, 2012 - 4:06 pm

    When are the CSD Board members going to start stepping down? Are they going to wait for the impending multi-million dollar law suit pending to be filed by Skeel. If I were Skeel I would not mediate because he has a clear-cut case that the CSD CANNOT defend. This means a potential $20 million lawsuit to the EDH CSD. That also means cuts in services to all the EDH families. I guess that means no summertime concerts, kids programs, Sr. programs, sports programs...etc... Heck the insurance deductible on a $20 million lawsuit will bankrupt the CSD. I guess the brilliant CSD board didn't think this one through.by the way, ending up in a lawsuit over Skeel was a complete failure of the CSD board. This Board is simply a failure and has got to go...



  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • Follow Us On Facebook

  • Special Publications »

    Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service (updated 4/30/2015) and Privacy Policy (updated 4/7/2015).
    Copyright (c) 2017 McNaughton Newspapers, Inc., a family-owned local media company that proudly publishes the Daily Republic, Mountain Democrat, Davis Enterprise, Village Life, Winters Express, Georgetown Gazette, EDC Adventures, and other community-driven publications.